Teaching faculty across institutions find themselves entrenched in the same challenges as the pre-COVID-19 world. However, research and anecdotal evidence point to enhanced traditional challenges along with new ones altogether. Finding ways to encourage academic curiosity and the true value of genuine student learning have never been more difficult. To address this challenge, five mid-career faculty evaluated Blum’s (2020) book, Ungrading: Why Rating Students Undermines Learning (and What to Do Instead), over a series of four seminars. The book revealed that applications of ungraded teaching methodologies must fit within a formally graded framework. The book also offered positive results along with the challenges of implementation and other outcomes. This teaching commentary is a report of the seminars and provides different suggestions to incorporate the positive aspects of the ungraded classroom into a traditional graded environment.

Allen, J.D. 2005. “Grades as Valid Measures of Academic Achievement of Classroom Learning.” The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas 78(5):218–223.

Allensworth, E.M., and K. Clark. 2020. “High School GPAs and ACT Scores as Predictors of College Completion: Examining Assumptions about Consistency Across High Schools.” Educational Researcher 49(3):198–211.

Barrett-Fox, R., B. Bayne, V. Cooper, and G. Espinosa. 2020. “How the Coronavirus Pandemic Will Change Our Future Teaching.” Religion and American Culture 30(2):147–186.

Blum, S. 2020. Ungrading: Why Rating Students Undermines Learning (and What to Do Instead). Morgantown: West Virginia University Press.

Godfrey, J. 2022. “Grades Do Not Define You: Mindfulness-Based Intervention Effects on College Students’ Self-Efficacy, Health, and Wellbeing.” West Chester University, Master’s Thesis.

Lin, T.C. 2009. “Endogenous Effects of Midterm Grades and Evaluations: A Simultaneous Framework.” Economics Bulletin 29(3):1731–1742.

Lipnevich, A.A., T.R. Guskey, D.M. Murano, and J.K. Smith. 2020. “What Do Grades Mean? Variation in Grading Criteria in American College and University Courses.” Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice 27(5):480–500.

Lv, X., J. Ma, T.M. Brinthaupt, S. Zhao, and X. Ren. 2022. “Impacts of University Lockdown During the Coronavirus Pandemic on College Students’ Academic Achievement and Critical Thinking: A Longitudinal Study.” Frontiers in Psychology 13:995784.

Picault, J. 2019. “The Economics Instructor’s Toolbox.” International Review of Economics Education 30:100154.

Pokhrel, S., and R. Chhetri. 2021. “A Literature Review on Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic on Teaching and Learning.” Higher Education for the Future 8(1):133–141.

Rashid, S., and S. Yadav. 2020. “Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic on Higher Education and Research.” Indian Journal of Human Development 14(2):340–343.

Saucier, D.A., T.L. Jones, A.A. Schiffer, and N.D. Renken. 2022. “The Empathetic Course Design Perspective.” Applied Economics Teaching Resources 4(4): 101–111.

Sterlitz, S.J., A.E. Karpenko, S.S. Garcia‐Hammaker, and A.J. Barragato. 2020. “Promoting Critical Thinking During a  Pandemic.” Journal of Dental Education 85(Suppl 1):1053.