Applied Economics Teaching Resources

an AAEA Journal

Agricultural and Applied Economics Association

Case Study

High Stakes: Managing Risk and Policy Uncertainty in the Market for CBD Food Products

Andrew W. Stevens(a) and Joy M. Pahl(b)
University of Wisconsin(a), St. Norbert College(b)

JEL Codes: A22, M13, Q13, Q14, Q18
Keywords: CBD, hemp, risk, start-up, uncertainty

Publish Date: October 4, 2021
Volume 3, Issue 4

View Full Article (PDF) | Request Teaching Notes/Supplemental Materials

Abstract

Consumer demand for food products containing cannabidiol (CBD) has skyrocketed in recent years. This spike in demand has presented an opening for entrepreneurial small businesses to seize a lucrative market opportunity. However, sourcing CBD is risky due to volatile prices and spotty availability in the wholesale market. Consequently, some entrepreneurs have considered producing their own CBD by growing hemp and vertically integrating their supply chains. This strategy poses its own risks: hemp that contains too much tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) must be destroyed; hemp yields are variable; and state- and federal-level policies about hemp production are changing rapidly. This case study follows the story of Levi Budz, a young entrepreneur from northeast Wisconsin, as he founded and grew Budz Butter: a 2017 startup company that produced CBD food products. This case focuses on risk management and decision making under uncertainty with particular attention to a shifting policy landscape, price volatility for a key input (CBD extract), hemp production risks, and uncertainty about consumer demand and competition in the retail marketplace. These themes are broadly applicable to other emerging opportunities in the agricultural and food sectors, and especially applicable to entrepreneurial ventures.

About the Authors: Andrew W. Stevens is Assistant Professor at University of Wisconsin—Madison (Corresponding author: awstevens@wisc.edu). Joy M. Pahl is Associate Professor at St. Norbert College. Acknowledgements: We wish to thank Levi Budz for sharing his experiences. We also appreciate feedback provided at the 2021 AAEA Annual Meeting’s Invited Case Study session. We declare no conflicts of interest or financial support for this case study.

Copyright is governed under Creative Commons CC BY-NC-SA

References

Abbott, B.A., and J.B. Zack. 2018. “Current Banking Issues in the Cannabis Industry.” The Consumer Finance Law Quarterly Report 72(4):390–396.

Brightfield Group. 2017. “Understanding Cannabidiol (CBD): Industry Expert Report.” Retrieved from https://content.brightfieldgroup.com/understanding-cbd-report-2017.

Brightfield Group. 2019. “From Farm to Aisle: U.S. CBD Market 2019 Report.” Retrieved from https://content.brightfieldgroup.com/2019-us-cbd-market.

Burney, S., and A. Remble. 2020. “2019 Wisconsin Hemp Marketing Study.” Renk Agribusiness Institute, University of Wisconsin–Madison. Retrieved from https://renk.aae.wisc.edu/2020/01/02/2019-wisconsin-hemp-marketing-study/.

Cannabis Benchmarks. 2017. “The Basics of Cannabis Price Risk Management.” Retrieved from https://www.cannabisbenchmarks.com/price-risk-report/.

Conley, S.P., J. Gaska, A. Roth, C. Skjolaas, E. Silva, L. Ortiz-Ribbing, W. Barker, and P. Robinson. 2018. “Wisconsin Industrial Hemp Production: A Basic FAQ Guide for Growing an Old Crop in a New Era.” University of Wisconsin-Extension. Retrieved from https://fyi.extension.wisc.edu/hemp/wisconsin-industrial-hemp-production-a-basic-faq-guide-for-growing-an-old-crop-in-a-new-era/.

Corroon, J., and R. Kight. 2018. “Regulatory Status of Cannabidiol in the United States: A Perspective.” Cannabis and Cannabinoid Research 3(1):190–194.

Darby, H. 2018. “2018 Industrial Grain Hemp Variety Trial.” University of Vermont Extension. Retrieved from https://www.uvm.edu/sites/default/files/media/2018_Grain_hemp_variety_trial.pdf.

Drotleff, L. 2020. “2020 Outlook: Licensed U.S. Hemp Acreage Falls 9% from 2019, but Grower Numbers Increase 27%.” Hemp Industry Daily. Retrieved from https://hempindustrydaily.com/2020-outlook-licensed-u-s-hemp-acreage-falls-9-from-2019-but-grower-numbers-increase-27/.

Hemp Business Journal. 2017. “Market Size: Hemp Industry Sales Grow to $688 Million in 2016.” Retrieved from https://www.hempbizjournal.com/market-size-hemp-industry-sales-grow-to-688-million-in-2016/.

Mead, A. 2017. “The Legal Status of Cannabis (Marijuana) and Cannabidiol (CBD) under U.S. Law.” Epilepsy & Behavior 70:288–291.

Owram, K. 2020. “Hemp Prices Plunge as CBD Demand Falls Short: Cannabis Weekly.” Bloomberg, January 27. Retrieved from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-01-26/hemp-prices-plunge-as-cbd-demand-falls-short-cannabis-weekly.

Parker, K.A., A. Di Mattia, F. Shaik, J.C. Cerón Ortega, and R. Whittle. 2019. “Risk Management within the Cannabis Industry: Building a Framework for the Cannabis Industry.” Financial Markets, Institutions & Instruments 28(1):3–55.

Raszap Skorbiansky, S., S. Thornsbury, and K.M. Camp. 2021. “Legal Risk Exposure Heightens Uncertainty in Developing U.S. Hemp Markets.” Choices 36(1).

Reed, J.K. 2018. “Impacts of Marijuana Legalization in Colorado.” Colorado Division of Criminal Justice. Retrieved from https://cdpsdocs.state.co.us/ors/docs/reports/2018-SB13-283_Rpt.pdf.

Williams, D.W., J.P. Perry, and T. Keene. 2017. “2017 University of Kentucky Industrial Hemp Variety Trials for Dual-Purpose Production.” University of Kentucky. Retrieved from http://hemp.ca.uky.edu/sites/hemp.ca.uky.edu/files/2017_dual_purpose_report.pdf.